Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Poly Mailers vs Kraft Mailers: Which One Should You Buy?

Poly mailers suit clothing and other non-fragile orders with a self-seal strip, while this guide lists no kraft mailer, so the kraft side stays unstated.

Poly Mailers vs Kraft Mailers: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Poly Mailers Shipping BagsPoly Mailers Shipping Bags9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2LINSIRON Poly Mailers 10x13 Inch 50 PcsLINSIRON Poly Mailers 10x13 Inch 50 Pcs9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Fuxury Poly Mailers 10x13 Inch 100 PackFuxury Poly Mailers 10x13 Inch 100 Pack9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Fuxury Poly Mailers 14.5x19 Inch 50pc Shipping Bags for SmallFuxury Poly Mailers 14.5x19 Inch 50pc Shipping Bags for SmallView on Amazon
  5. 5Metronic Poly Mailers 10x13 100 PcsMetronic Poly Mailers 10x13 100 PcsView on Amazon
  6. 6Metronic Large Poly Mailers 14.5x19 50PC Clothes ShippingMetronic Large Poly Mailers 14.5x19 50PC Clothes ShippingView on Amazon
  7. 7Metronic Poly Mailers 14.5x19 50PC Large Shipping Bags inMetronic Poly Mailers 14.5x19 50PC Large Shipping Bags inView on Amazon

A stack of finished orders waits by the bench: folded shirts, books and accessories, all ready for the mail. The question is which bag protects them on the way to the buyer, and the short answer for poly mailers vs kraft mailers is that the poly mailers in this guide cover the job with a self-seal strip, and the Fuxury and SMARTYnas listings state a water-resistant or waterproof build, while no kraft mailer appears among the listed products, so the kraft side stays unstated here. Read the poly options below, match the size to the parcel, and choose kraft only from a listing that states its material and size.

Other machines to compare

LaserEngraveHQ earns a commission from purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Honest note

This guide lists poly mailers only. No kraft mailer listing was provided, so kraft sizes, materials and pack counts stay unstated, and the picks below are all poly mailers.

Poly mailers vs kraft mailers: the short answer

Poly mailers suit clothing and other non-fragile items that fit the bag, with a self-seal strip and, in the Fuxury and SMARTYnas listings, a water-resistant or waterproof build. Kraft mailers have no listing in this guide, so this guide names no kraft size, material or pack count. For the orders the listings cover, poly is the stated choice. For kraft, pick from a listing that states the bag material and the size, the same way the poly listings below state theirs.

What poly mailers do well

Poly mailers ship light and less fragile products. The white Fuxury listing names clothing and accessories, jewelry, lip gloss, cosmetics and beauty products, and books, and the pink Fuxury listing names apparel and accessories, shirts, shoes, jeans, books and cosmetics. The white Fuxury bag is tear-resistant, puncture-resistant and waterproof, with a self-sealing adhesive strip that is tamper-resistant and tamper-evident, and the film is fully opaque for confidentiality. The SMARTYnas bags use multi-layer LDPE that is tear and water resistant, with a matte surface that accepts thermal labels and scans cleanly, reinforced sides that add stretch and puncture resistance, and seams that lie flat in sacks and conveyors. The SMARTYnas listing also says the strong seal supports delivery in rainy, foggy or dusty conditions.

The SMARTYnas pack states its bags are not padded, with no bubble lining, so breakable items need inner wrap or a box. The KKBESTPACK listing says the same for its bags: add separate packing material or a box for rigid, sharp or breakable items, and use the bags for flexible, non-fragile contents.

Poly mailers in this guide

The 4 poly mailers below start with the multi-size pack, then the packs in 1 size.

  • SMARTYnas multi-size pack. A 30 pack in 3 sizes: 8×12, 10×13 and 14×19, with 10 of each size. The multi-layer LDPE build is tear and water resistant, the matte grey surface accepts thermal labels, and the bags suit T-shirts, shirts, jeans, knitwear, catalogs and bedding. Not padded, with no bubble lining.
  • Fuxury white 10×13, 100 pack. A white poly mailer for clothing, books and accessories, with a strong self-sealing adhesive strip, a tear-resistant and puncture-resistant build, and a fully opaque film for confidentiality.
  • KKBESTPACK black 10×13, 100 pack. A black poly mailer for clothing and other non-fragile items, with a covered adhesive strip: remove the liner, fold the flap and press across it. The listing says to add separate packing material or a box for rigid, sharp or breakable items.
  • Fuxury pink 14.5×19, 50 pack. A light pink poly mailer for clothing and accessories, with a strong adhesive self-sealing strip and reinforced edge sealing that is tear-resistant and waterproof.

How to pick a size

Match the bag to the parcel. A 10×13 bag fits tees, per the SMARTYnas listing, and the 10×13 size appears in the white and black 100 packs and in the multi-size pack. The SMARTYnas listing calls its 14×19 bag a large mailer for clothing orders, and the 14.5×19 pink mailer gives more room still for larger items. An 8×12 bag is the smallest size in the multi-size pack. The multi-size pack lets a seller right-size each parcel. Check the dimensions and the pack count before packing, and the SMARTYnas listing says to store the bags flat and away from heat to protect the adhesive.

When kraft mailers come up

Kraft mailers are the other side of this comparison, and this guide has no kraft listing to draw on. No kraft size, material, seal type or pack count is stated here, so this guide cannot say which kraft bag fits a given order. A seller who wants kraft should look for a listing that states the bag material, the size and the seal, the same way the poly listings above state theirs. Until then, the poly mailers above are the only picks this guide can name.

FAQ: lasers and CNC

Which mailer suits clothing orders?

Poly mailers suit clothing orders. The listings cover T-shirts, shirts, jeans, knitwear and other non-fragile clothing, with a self-seal strip; the Fuxury and SMARTYnas listings state a water-resistant or waterproof build. Match the size to the folded garment: 10×13 for tees, per the SMARTYnas listing, and 14×19 for larger orders.

Do poly mailers keep rain out?

The Fuxury and SMARTYnas listings state a water-resistant or waterproof build. The Fuxury bags are waterproof with reinforced edge sealing, and the SMARTYnas bags are tear and water resistant. The white Fuxury listing also states a tamper-resistant seal, and the white Fuxury and SMARTYnas listings state an opaque film that keeps the contents private. Poly mailers still suit non-fragile contents only.

What size poly mailer fits a folded shirt?

A 10×13 poly mailer fits tees, per the SMARTYnas listing, and the 10×13 size appears in the white and black 100 packs and in the multi-size pack. For larger folded items, the 14×19 size in the multi-size pack or the 14.5×19 pink mailer gives more room.

Can poly mailers ship books and accessories?

Yes, for non-fragile items. The white Fuxury listing names books and accessories, and the pink Fuxury listing names apparel, accessories, shirts, shoes, jeans, books and cosmetics. Add inner wrap for breakables, since the bags are not padded.

What about breakable items in a poly mailer?

Poly mailers are for non-fragile contents. The KKBESTPACK listing says to add separate packing material or a box for rigid, sharp or breakable items, and the SMARTYnas listing says the bags are not padded and to add inner wrap for breakables. For breakables, the KKBESTPACK listing points to a box.

Related: poly mailers vs bubble mailers, packing peanuts vs bubble wrap and shipping vs packing tape. Also see our impulse sealer vs handheld heat sealer. Also see our shipping box sizes. Also see our lowest price shipping boxes. Also see our price label gun. Also see our dimensions of bubble mailer.

More related guides (8)

More buying guides

Packaging and Craft Fairs ·

Poly Mailer Sizes: Dimensions and Chart

Match the mailer to the item, check the usable size, and pick a pack in 8x12, 10x13, 14x19 or 14.5x19 for shipping soft goods.