Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Shipping vs Packing Tape: Which One Should You Buy?

Shipping tape and packing tape name the same 1.88 in box tape; length, adhesive and dispenser are what separate the tapes in this guide.

Shipping vs Packing Tape: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1HKHKPI Bluetooth Thermal Label PrinterHKHKPI Bluetooth Thermal Label Printer9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Amazon Basics Packaging Tape Dispenser GunAmazon Basics Packaging Tape Dispenser Gun9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Mr. Pen- Heavy Duty Packing Tape Dispenser GunMr. Pen- Heavy Duty Packing Tape Dispenser Gun9.4/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Scotch Heavy Duty Shipping Packing TapeScotch Heavy Duty Shipping Packing TapeView on Amazon
  5. 5Scotch Heavy Duty Shipping Packaging Tape 3850Scotch Heavy Duty Shipping Packaging Tape 3850View on Amazon
  6. 6AUDTMWH Packing Tape RefillsAUDTMWH Packing Tape RefillsView on Amazon
  7. 7JoyfuIMaiMaiMai Clear Packing TapeJoyfuIMaiMaiMai Clear Packing TapeView on Amazon
  8. 8P PERFECTAPE Heavy Duty Packing Tape 6 RollsP PERFECTAPE Heavy Duty Packing Tape 6 RollsView on Amazon
  9. 9JARLINK 12 Rolls Clear Packing TapeJARLINK 12 Rolls Clear Packing TapeView on Amazon

Shipping tape and packing tape are the same product wearing different names. The names describe the same product: a clear plastic tape that seals boxes, so the name on the pack is not the choice. Shipping vs packing tape comes down to width, length, adhesive and dispenser: the roll that fits your boxes and your dispenser is the right roll, whatever the pack calls it.

Other machines to compare

LaserEngraveHQ earns a commission from purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Honest note

No maker here states a tape thickness, so this guide compares width, length, adhesive and dispenser only. Roll length is given per roll, not per pack, because the packs hold different roll counts.

Shipping vs packing tape: what the names mean

The names overlap on every tape here. Scotch calls its tape heavy duty tape for boxes, shipping, moving and storage, and also calls it shipping packing tape. Amazon Basics calls it packing tape for shipping, sealing boxes, moving and storage. Duck calls it packing tape for packing and moving boxes, mailing, shipping and storage. The shared job is sealing a box shut, and the shared form is a clear plastic roll listed at 1.88 in wide. What differs is the adhesive, the length per roll, the roll count and the dispenser.

What separates one tape from another

Width does not separate these tapes: each roll lists 1.88 in wide. Length per roll does: the Scotch 6-roll pack gives 22.2 yd per roll, the Scotch 1-roll pack gives 27.7 yd, and the Amazon Basics and Duck rolls give 54.6 yd each. Roll count runs from 1 to 12, with the Amazon Basics pack holding 12 rolls, the Scotch 6-roll and Duck packs holding 6, and the Scotch 1-roll pack holding 1. Adhesive differs by maker: Scotch uses an industrial-strength, solvent-free adhesive, Amazon Basics uses an acrylic polymer water-based adhesive, and Duck uses a bond that strengthens over time. Dispenser is the last split: the Scotch packs include one, while the Amazon Basics and Duck rolls fit 3 inch dispensers.

The gear

The tapes below are ordered by how much each one covers for shipping use: dispenser, length, adhesive and box types.

Tape Width Length per roll Rolls Dispenser Adhesive
Scotch Heavy Duty, 6 rolls 1.88 in 22.2 yd 6 Included Industrial-strength, solvent-free
Duck HD Clear, 6 rolls 1.88 in 54.6 yd 6 Fits most 3in core dispensers Bond strengthens over time
Amazon Basics, 12-pack 1.88 in 54.6 yd 12 Fits 3 inch dispensers Acrylic polymer, water-based
Scotch Heavy Duty, 1 roll 1.88 in 27.7 yd 1 Included Industrial-strength, solvent-free

Scotch Heavy Duty, 6 rolls: the full kit

Scotch Heavy Duty Packing Tape in the 6-roll pack is the full kit. Each roll is 1.88 in x 22.2 yd on a 1.5-in core, and a dispenser comes with the pack for precise cuts, with fall-back tabs that keep the tape ready for the next use. The industrial-strength, solvent-free adhesive adheres instantly and works on all box types, including harder-to-stick 100% recycled boxes. One strip on each seam is enough, and the tape resists slivering, splitting and tearing. The maker states a limited warranty.

Duck HD Clear, 6 rolls: the long refill

Duck HD Clear Heavy Duty Packing Tape in the 6-roll pack is the long refill. Each roll is 1.88 in x 54.6 yds on a 3 inch core, and the rolls fit most 3in core dispensers. The adhesive bond strengthens over time for a long-lasting hold, and the tape offers wide temperature performance, sticking well in hot or cold temperatures. It is crystal clear to the core, meets postal regulations for shipping and mailing tape, and cuts with scissors. The maker gives 2 in and 1.88 in; check before ordering.

Amazon Basics, 12-pack: the bulk box

Amazon Basics Strong Plastic Adhesive Packing Tape in the 12-pack is the bulk box. Each roll is 1.88 in x 54.6 yds, and the pack holds 12 rolls. The acrylic polymer water-based adhesive gives high-performance holding power, and the crystal clear tape holds up to shipping, handling, long-distance transit and storage. It works with 3 inch dispensers or tape guns to cut tape at the desired length, and it keeps address labels in place.

Scotch Heavy Duty, 1 roll: the small pack

Scotch Heavy Duty Packing Tape in the 1-roll pack is the small pack. The roll is 1.88 in x 27.7 yd on a 1.5-in core, with the same industrial-strength, solvent-free adhesive and the same dispenser as the 6-roll pack. It works on all box types, including harder-to-stick 100% recycled boxes, and one strip on each seam is enough. It suits one box or a small move.

How to pick a tape for shipping

Start with the dispenser. If you have no dispenser, the Scotch packs include one with precise cuts and fall-back tabs; if you own a 3 inch dispenser or tape gun, the Amazon Basics refills fit it and the Duck refills fit most 3in core dispensers. Then count the boxes: the 12-pack suits a run of parcels, while the 1-roll pack suits one box or a small move. For recycled boxes, Scotch states its tape works on harder-to-stick 100% recycled boxes. For hot or cold storage, Duck states wide temperature performance. For address labels, Amazon Basics and Duck state the tape keeps address labels in place.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Buying refills when you own no dispenser.
  • Judging a pack by roll count alone; check the length per roll too.
  • Assuming every tape suits recycled boxes; only Scotch states it.
  • Ordering by the name on the pack; shipping tape and packing tape are the same kind of tape.
  • Skipping the width check; the Duck maker gives 2 in and 1.88 in.

Shipping vs packing tape: the short version

  1. Shipping tape and packing tape are the same kind of tape.
  2. Compare width, length per roll, adhesive and dispenser.
  3. Pick the Scotch 6-roll pack for a dispenser and recycled boxes.
  4. Pick the Duck or Amazon Basics rolls for the longest length per roll.
  5. Check the width before ordering: the Duck maker gives 2 in and 1.88 in.
  6. Match the tape to the dispenser you own or buy.

FAQ: lasers and CNC

Is shipping tape the same as packing tape?

Yes. Each name here covers the same kind of tape: clear plastic tape listed at 1.88 in wide, for sealing boxes. The choice is width, length per roll, adhesive and dispenser, not the name on the pack.

What width of packing tape should you buy?

The tapes here are all 1.88 in wide. The Duck maker also gives 2 in, so check the width before ordering.

How do you use a shipping tape gun?

Use a 3 inch dispenser or tape gun with the roll. The Amazon Basics tape works with 3 inch dispensers or tape guns to cut tape at the desired length, and the Scotch dispenser provides precise cuts with fall-back tabs that keep the tape ready for the next use.

How much tape is on a roll?

It depends on the roll. The Scotch 6-roll pack gives 22.2 yd per roll, the Scotch 1-roll pack gives 27.7 yd, and the Amazon Basics and Duck rolls give 54.6 yd each. Check the length per roll, not the pack count, when you compare.

Does packing tape work on recycled boxes?

Scotch states its tape works on all box types, including harder-to-stick 100% recycled boxes. Amazon Basics and Duck do not state recycled-box use, so check their wording before ordering for recycled boxes.

Related: small business gear, best shipping label printer and best label maker.

More buying guides

Packaging and Craft Fairs ·

How Do You Load Packing Tape Dispenser

Learn how to load a packing tape dispenser: fit the roll on the core, thread the tape to the blade, set the brake and…