Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Lead Free vs Leaded Solder: Which One Should You Buy?

Lead-free solder suits stained glass, jewelry and drinking-water plumbing, while lead solder stays off food-contact work.

Lead Free vs Leaded Solder: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Helping Hands Clamp MetalHelping Hands Clamp Metal9.4/10View on Amazon
  2. 2AIM Artist Pure Lead-Free Stained Glass SolderAIM Artist Pure Lead-Free Stained Glass SolderView on Amazon
  3. 3ZSHX Lead Free Solder Wire Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7 Rosin core solderZSHX Lead Free Solder Wire Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7 Rosin core solderView on Amazon
  4. 4AIM Lead-Free Plumbing SolderAIM Lead-Free Plumbing SolderView on Amazon
  5. 5Lead-Free Solder Wire Rosin Core Flux 0.8mm Electric SolderLead-Free Solder Wire Rosin Core Flux 0.8mm Electric SolderView on Amazon
  6. 6Lead-Free Solder Wire Rosin Core No Lead Wire Thin 0.6mm 50gLead-Free Solder Wire Rosin Core No Lead Wire Thin 0.6mm 50gView on Amazon
  7. 72.0mm Lead Free Solder Wire for Stained Glass Craft2.0mm Lead Free Solder Wire for Stained Glass CraftView on Amazon

Stained glass, jewelry and a small electronics repair all end at the same bench, and lead free vs leaded solder is the choice that decides which alloy joins the work. Lead-free solder suits stained glass that gets handled often, jewelry, and plumbing that carries drinking water, while lead solder stays off food-contact work. The 4 solders in this guide are all lead-free, and the sections below show which one fits each job.

Other machines to compare

LaserEngraveHQ earns a commission from purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Honest note

Every solder in this guide is lead-free, so the leaded side of the comparison is described in general terms rather than from a leaded solder in this guide.

Step 1: Match the solder to the job

Start from the work, not the spool. Stained glass and jewelry take the AIM Artist Pure alloy, which the maker designed with the glass artist in mind and lists for stained glass, artware, jewelry, crafts and general soldering. Electronics take a thin rosin core wire: the ZSHX and ENERSYSTEC wires are both 0.8 mm rosin core wire in the Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7 alloy, made for electrical soldering and small components. Plumbing takes the AIM Lead-Free Plumbing Solder, a solid wire the maker lists for brass and copper plumbing joints and pipes, and which complies with ASTM B32 requirements for soldering potable water connections.

Each solder in this guide lists its own melting point: the Artist Pure alloy lists 407°F to 439°F, the ZSHX wire lists 217℃/422.6℉, the plumbing solder lists 214C to 234C (416F to 454F), and the ENERSYSTEC wire lists 419F. Lead-free alloys generally need more heat than leaded solder, so check the melting point the alloy lists before you set the iron.

Step 2: Read the alloy before you buy

The alloy is the solder. The ZSHX and ENERSYSTEC wires are Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7: tin 99%, silver 0.3% and copper 0.7%, with a rosin core; the ZSHX wire lists 2% flux content. The AIM plumbing solder is a silver bearing alloy of 95.75% tin, 0.25% silver, 3% copper and 1% antimony, in a solid wire. The Artist Pure alloy is a high purity silver bearing lead-free alloy, with a strong bond, excellent flow and a smooth, bright solder bead.

Diameter helps decide where the wire fits: the electronics wires are 0.8 mm, while the stained-glass and plumbing solders are 0.125 inch, or 3 mm. A thin wire suits small components and fine joints; a thick wire suits a stained-glass seam and a plumbing joint.

Step 3: The 4 lead-free solders in this guide

The solders below run in order, from the most certified to the simplest wire: the plumbing solder first, then the stained-glass alloy, then the two electronics wires.

AIM Lead-Free Plumbing Solder. A 1 lb (454 g) spool of solid wire, 0.125 inch in diameter, melting at 214C to 234C (416F to 454F). The alloy is 95.75% tin, 0.25% silver, 3% copper and 1% antimony, and the maker lists high tensile strength. It complies with ASTM B32 requirements for soldering potable water connections, is certified NSF and UPC, and meets all state and federal specifications for the Safe Drinking Water Act. The maker lists brass and copper plumbing joints and pipes, plus stained glass, jewelry and general soldering on non ferrous metals.

AIM Artist Pure Lead-Free Stained Glass Solder. A 1 lb (454 g) spool of 0.125 inch wire, 3 mm, in a high purity silver bearing lead-free alloy, melting at 407°F to 439°F. The maker lists a strong bond with excellent flow for a smooth, bright solder bead, designed with the glass artist in mind for stained glass, artware, jewelry, crafts and general soldering, and ideal where the final products may be frequently handled.

ZSHX Lead Free Solder Wire. A rosin core wire of 0.8 mm, or 0.0315 inch, in the Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7 alloy, with 2% flux content and a melting point of 217℃/422.6℉. The spool holds 50 g, or 0.11 lbs, and the maker lists electrical soldering and small components among the uses.

ENERSYSTEC Lead-Free Solder Wire. A rosin core wire of 0.8 mm, or 0.032 in, in the Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7 alloy, melting at 419F. The spool holds 50 g, or 0.11 lb, and the maker lists electronics soldering, small components, MCUs, rework, electrical wire soldering and appliance repair. No extra flux is needed, as the flux core flows well for connectors, PCBs and small components.

Step 4: Set up a safe soldering spot

Soldering for stained glass calls for ventilation, eye protection and a heat-proof surface, and the work stays off food-contact pieces when lead solder is in use: lead solder is not for food-contact items. Work with the window open or a fan moving air away from the bench, wear eye protection, and set the work on a heat-proof surface.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Using lead solder on a food-contact piece: lead solder is not for food-contact items.
  • Picking a solder by diameter alone, without reading the alloy and the melting point the maker lists.
  • Buying a solid wire for electronics and then adding flux by hand, when the rosin core wires in this guide carry their own flux.
  • Using the plumbing solder for electronics: the maker lists plumbing joints and pipes, stained glass and jewelry, not small components.
  • Skipping ventilation: soldering for stained glass calls for ventilation, eye protection and a heat-proof surface.

Lead free vs leaded solder: the short version

  1. Match the solder to the job: stained glass, electronics or plumbing.
  2. Read the alloy: Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7 for the electronics wires, and the silver bearing alloy for the AIM solders.
  3. Check the diameter: 0.8 mm for electronics, 0.125 inch for glass and plumbing.
  4. Set up ventilation, eye protection and a heat-proof surface.
  5. Keep lead solder off food-contact work.
  6. Use lead-free solder for stained glass that gets handled often and for plumbing that carries drinking water.

FAQ: lasers and CNC

Is lead-free solder safe for drinking water pipes?

The AIM plumbing solder complies with ASTM B32 requirements for soldering potable water connections, is certified NSF and UPC, and meets all state and federal specifications for the Safe Drinking Water Act.

Can I use lead-free solder for stained glass?

Yes. The AIM Artist Pure alloy is designed with the glass artist in mind and lists stained glass among its uses, and the AIM plumbing solder also lists stained glass. The Artist Pure alloy lists a melting point of 407°F to 439°F and a strong bond with excellent flow.

What does Sn99 Ag0.3 Cu0.7 mean?

It is the alloy mix the ZSHX and ENERSYSTEC wires state: tin 99%, silver 0.3% and copper 0.7%. Both wires are rosin core wire of 0.8 mm for electrical soldering.

Do I need extra flux with rosin core solder?

For the ENERSYSTEC wire, no: the maker states no extra flux is needed, and the flux core flows well for connectors, PCBs and small components. The ZSHX wire lists 2% flux content in its rosin core.

What size solder wire do I need?

For electronics, the wires in this guide are 0.8 mm, with the ZSHX wire listing 0.0315 inch and the ENERSYSTEC wire listing 0.032 in. For stained glass and plumbing, the AIM solders are 0.125 inch, or 3 mm.

Can lead solder touch food?

No. Lead solder is not for food-contact items. Use a lead-free solder for work that touches food or drinking water, such as the AIM plumbing solder.

Related: the soldering gun vs soldering iron and soldering iron vs soldering station guides. Also see the best label maker for home use and best 5 in 1 heat press under 150 picks.

More buying guides