Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Sublimation Paper vs Heat Transfer Paper: Which One Should You Buy?

Two transfer papers for custom shirts, mugs and gifts, compared on the materials, printers and inks each listing states.

Sublimation Paper vs Heat Transfer Paper: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1A-SUB Sublimation Paper 11x17 Inch 110 Sheets 125gA-SUB Sublimation Paper 11x17 Inch 110 Sheets 125g9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2A-SUB Sublimation Paper 8.5x14 Inch 110 SheetsA-SUB Sublimation Paper 8.5x14 Inch 110 Sheets9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3HTVRONT Heat Transfer Paper for Dark T ShirtsHTVRONT Heat Transfer Paper for Dark T Shirts9.6/10View on Amazon

A custom shirt, a printed mug and a gift tumbler all start with the same question: which transfer paper fits the project, the printer and the fabric in front of you. This comparison looks at sublimation paper vs heat transfer paper through the listings in this comparison, so you can match the paper to the material instead of guessing.

LaserEngraveHQ earns a commission from purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Verdict: pick sublimation paper if you print on white or light colored polyester, or on coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic and tile, phone cases and metal plates, and you already run a sublimation printer with sublimation ink. Pick heat transfer paper if you print dark cotton shirts on an inkjet printer with dye ink or pigment ink. The printer and the fabric decide the side.

Machines on the list

A-SUB Sublimation Paper 11x17 Inch 110 Sheets 125g

A-SUB Sublimation Paper 11x17 Inch 110 Sheets 125g

A-SUB9.6/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A sublimation paper pack for large transfers on white or light colored polyester and coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic and tile, phone cases and metal plates, for use with a sublimation printer and sublimation ink.

Pros

  • 11x17 inch sheets for larger designs
  • Transfer rate of at least 98% stated in the listing
  • Works on white or light colored polyester and coated mugs, tumblers
  • 110 sheets per pack for repeat projects

Cons

  • Only works with sublimation printers and sublimation ink
  • Not for dark fabrics: white or light colors only
  • Cotton content limited to 30% or less
  • No warranty term stated in the listing
A-SUB Sublimation Paper 8.5x14 Inch 110 Sheets

A-SUB Sublimation Paper 8.5x14 Inch 110 Sheets

A-SUB9.6/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A sublimation paper pack for smaller transfers on white or light colored polyester and coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic and tile, phone cases and metal plates, for use with a sublimation printer and sublimation ink.

Pros

  • 8.5x14 inch sheets for smaller transfers
  • Transfer rate of at least 98% stated in the listing
  • Works on white or light colored polyester and coated mugs, tumblers
  • 110 sheets per pack for repeat projects

Cons

  • Only works with sublimation printers and sublimation ink
  • Not for dark fabrics: white or light colors only
  • Cotton content limited to 30% or less
  • No warranty term stated in the listing
HTVRONT Heat Transfer Paper for Dark T Shirts

HTVRONT Heat Transfer Paper for Dark T Shirts

HTVRONT9.6/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A heat transfer paper for dark colored cotton shirts, printed on an inkjet printer and applied with a home iron or heat press.

Pros

  • Made for dark colored cotton or cotton/poly blend fabric
  • Works with an inkjet printer, dye ink and pigment ink
  • Heat press settings stated: 320-338°F for 8-12 seconds
  • Listing states durability through repeated washes without fading, cracking or peeling

Cons

  • 20 sheets per pack, fewer than the sublimation packs
  • Made for dark fabric, not a general light-fabric paper
  • Needs an inkjet printer: dye ink and pigment ink only
  • No warranty term stated in the listing

Other machines to compare

Side by side

Spec A-SUB 11×17 125g A-SUB 8.5×14 125g HTVRONT Dark Transfer
HQ Score 59 58 56
Side Sublimation paper Sublimation paper Heat transfer paper
Sheet size 11×17 inches 8.5×14 inches 8.5×11 inches
Sheets per pack 110 110 20
Paper weight 125g 125g Not stated in the listing
Transfer rate At least 98% At least 98% Not stated in the listing
Printer and ink Sublimation printer and sublimation ink Sublimation printer and sublimation ink Inkjet printer, dye ink and pigment ink
Heat press settings Not stated in the listing Not stated in the listing 320-338°F for 8-12 seconds
Materials the listing states White or light colored polyester, cotton content up to 30%, coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic and tile, phone cases, metal plates White or light colored polyester, cotton content up to 30%, coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic and tile, phone cases, metal plates Dark colored cotton or cotton/poly blend fabric
Warranty Not stated in the listing Not stated in the listing Not stated in the listing

We give each product’s specs as its manufacturer rates them; listings read 4 November 2026.

Sublimation Paper vs Heat Transfer Paper: Materials and Printers

The split between the sides starts with fabric color. Both A-SUB listings apply to white or light colored polyester, with cotton content capped at 30%, plus coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic and tile, phone cases and metal plates. The HTVRONT listing goes the other way: it is made for dark colored cotton or cotton/poly blend fabric, from shirts to home decorations and handmade presents.

Printers split the sides just as sharply. The A-SUB listings only work with a sublimation printer and sublimation ink, and the listings state plainly that regular ink does not work. The HTVRONT listing only works with inkjet printers, dye ink and pigment ink, and it applies with a home iron or a heat press. So the paper must match the printer and the ink already in the room.

Durability claims also differ in kind. The A-SUB listings state a transfer rate of at least 98%, with fast drying and no fracturing. The HTVRONT listing states vivid colors and durability through repeated washes without fading, cracking and peeling.

Sheet Sizes and Pack Sizes

Sheet size is where the two sublimation listings part ways. The larger A-SUB listing gives sheets of 11×17 inches, while the smaller gives 8.5×14 inches, and both packs hold 110 sheets at 125g. The HTVRONT listing gives sheets of 8.5×11 inches in a pack of 20 sheets, and the listing states no paper weight. The sublimation packs hold more sheets than the heat transfer pack.

Only the HTVRONT listing states heat press settings, at 320-338°F for 8-12 seconds; neither A-SUB listing states press settings.

Choose sublimation paper if

  • You print on white or light colored polyester, with cotton content at 30% or less.
  • You print on coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic, tile, phone cases or metal plates.
  • You already run a sublimation printer with sublimation ink.

Choose heat transfer paper if

  • You print on dark colored cotton or cotton/poly blend shirts.
  • You print on an inkjet printer with dye ink or pigment ink.
  • You apply transfers with a home iron, or with a heat press at the stated settings.
Safety

A heat press runs hot: the HTVRONT listing states 320-338°F for 8-12 seconds. Keep hands clear of the heated surface and let pressed items cool before handling.

Project Match

  • Light polyester shirts and gifts: either A-SUB listing, for white or light colored polyester with cotton content at 30% or less.
  • Coated mugs, tumblers, ceramic, tile, phone cases and metal plates: either A-SUB listing, since the listings state mugs must be coated and list those surfaces.
  • Sheet sizes: the A-SUB 11×17 listing for larger designs, the 8.5×14 listing for smaller designs.
  • Dark cotton shirts: the HTVRONT listing, made for dark colored cotton or cotton/poly blend fabric.

FAQ: lasers and CNC

Can sublimation paper work in a regular inkjet printer?

No. The A-SUB listings state the paper only works with a sublimation printer and sublimation ink, and regular ink does not work.

Does heat transfer paper work on dark shirts?

The HTVRONT listing is made for dark colored cotton or cotton/poly blend fabric, so dark shirts are its stated use. It is not the listing for white or light polyester.

Can sublimation paper go on cotton shirts?

Only within the limits the listings state: white or light colored polyester, with cotton content at 30% or less. A dark cotton shirt falls outside those limits.

What heat press settings does the HTVRONT listing state?

The listing states 320-338°F for 8-12 seconds as heat press settings, and it also states a home iron can be used. Neither A-SUB listing states press settings.

Related: sublimation vs heat transfer vinyl, best sublimation printer for mugs, sublimation printer vs inkjet printer and best t-shirt heat press machine.

More buying guides

Heat Presses and Sublimation ·

Best Heat Transfer Paper (2026)

5 heat transfer paper packs for light and dark fabrics compared by sheet count, printer type, ink and fabric.