Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Stencil Film vs Stencil Vinyl: Which One Should You Buy?

A Cricut film roll, a set of ZICOTO mylar sheets and a VViViD masking vinyl roll compared on size, adhesive, surfaces and reuse, so you can pick the side that fits your project.

Stencil Film vs Stencil Vinyl: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Easy Cut Stencil Sheet Set of 24-12x12 MylarEasy Cut Stencil Sheet Set of 24-12x12 Mylar9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Cricut® Stencil Film, Flexible (12 in x 12 ft)Cricut® Stencil Film, Flexible (12 in x 12 ft)9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3VViViD Matte Transparent Masking Stencil VinylVViViD Matte Transparent Masking Stencil Vinyl9.6/10View on Amazon

A stencil turns a plain sign, wall, glass panel or canvas into a repeatable design, and the material you cut it from decides how clean the lines come out and how easy the film is to place. This comparison looks at stencil film vs stencil vinyl through listings on Amazon: a Cricut film roll, a set of ZICOTO mylar sheets and a VViViD masking vinyl roll, and sorts out which side suits which project.

LaserEngraveHQ earns a commission from purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Verdict: pick the Cricut Stencil Film when you want a long roll for walls, glass, wood and canvas with an adhesive that removes without residue. Pick the ZICOTO Stencil Sheets when you want a pack of reusable mylar sheets for signs and curved surfaces. Pick the VViViD Stencil Vinyl when you want a low tack masking vinyl for spray paint and paint work on rigid, smooth surfaces.

Machines on the list

Easy Cut Stencil Sheet Set of 24-12x12 Mylar

Easy Cut Stencil Sheet Set of 24-12x12 Mylar

ZICOTO9.6/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A set of 24 mylar stencil sheets at 12 x 12 in, 4 mil thick, washable and reusable for signs and craft projects.

Pros

  • 24 sheets of 12 x 12 in mylar for many projects
  • Stated thickness of 4 mil / 0.1mm for lasting use
  • Washable and reusable, with flexible and bendable sheets
  • Works on wooden signs, metal, walls, glass and ceramics, including curved surfaces

Cons

  • No adhesive is stated in the listing
  • The sheets are mylar, listed as an alternative to stencil vinyl sheets
  • Only the 12 x 12 in sheet size is stated
  • No warranty term is stated
Cricut® Stencil Film, Flexible (12 in x 12 ft)

Cricut® Stencil Film, Flexible (12 in x 12 ft)

Cricut9.6/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A translucent stencil film roll, 12 in x 12 ft, with a durable adhesive that removes without residue, for walls, glass, wood and canvas.

Pros

  • 1 roll of 12 in x 12 ft film
  • Translucent film for easy alignment
  • Durable adhesive that removes without residue
  • Stated for walls, glass, wood and canvas, on curved and flat surfaces

Cons

  • No thickness is stated in the listing
  • No reuse is stated in the listing
  • The listing does not state which cutting machines it works with
  • No warranty term is stated
VViViD Matte Transparent Masking Stencil Vinyl

VViViD Matte Transparent Masking Stencil Vinyl

VViViD9.6/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A transparent masking stencil vinyl roll, 12 in x 6 ft, with a low tack acrylic adhesive for spray paint and paint work on rigid, smooth surfaces.

Pros

  • Formulated for stencil applications, especially spray paint and paint techniques
  • Low tack, acrylic-based adhesive that leaves no messy or sticky residue once removed
  • Transparent film for background visibility
  • Compatible with most vinyl cutting machines and trims by hand

Cons

  • Stated for rigid, smooth surfaces only
  • No thickness is stated in the listing
  • No reuse is stated in the listing

Other machines to compare

Side by side

Spec ZICOTO Stencil Sheets Cricut Stencil Film VViViD Stencil Vinyl
HQ Score 60 59 56
Format 24 sheets, 12 x 12 in 1 roll, 12 in x 12 ft 1 roll, 12 in x 6 ft
Material Mylar, 4 mil / 0.1mm Translucent film Transparent masking vinyl
Adhesive Not stated in the listing Durable, removes without residue Low tack, acrylic-based, no residue
Reusable Washable and reusable Not stated in the listing Not stated in the listing
Surfaces stated Wood, metal, walls, glass, ceramics Walls, glass, wood, canvas Art board, wood, drywall, glass, primed canvas
Cutting Cut with a cutting machine Not stated in the listing Most vinyl cutting machines; trims by hand

Specs are what each manufacturer publishes as its rating on the listing, collected 5 November 2026.

Stencil film vs stencil vinyl: size and format

The Cricut Stencil Film comes as 1 roll of 12 in x 12 ft. The ZICOTO set comes as 24 sheets of 12 x 12 in. The VViViD Stencil Vinyl comes as 1 roll of 12 in x 6 ft. The Cricut roll and the VViViD roll state their size as a length, while the ZICOTO set is the only pack of separate sheets in this comparison.

Adhesive and placement

The Cricut listing states a durable adhesive that removes without residue, and a translucent film for easy alignment. The VViViD listing states a low tack, acrylic-based adhesive that leaves no messy or sticky residue once removed. The ZICOTO listing states no adhesive, and the sheets are placed as mylar sheets rather than an adhesive-backed vinyl.

Surfaces and projects

The Cricut listing names walls, glass, wood and canvas. The ZICOTO listing names wooden signs, artwork on metal, walls, glass and ceramics, and notes curved surfaces. The VViViD listing names art board, wood, drywall, glass, mounted watercolour paper and primed canvas, and limits adhesion to rigid, smooth surfaces.

Reuse and cleanup

The ZICOTO sheets are washable and reusable, which the listing states directly. The Cricut listing does not state reuse. The VViViD listing does not state reuse, and instead states that the adhesive leaves no messy or sticky residue once removed.

Cutting machines and hand trimming

The ZICOTO listing says to cut the stencils with a cutting machine. The VViViD listing states compatibility with most vinyl cutting machines, and says the vinyl can be trimmed by hand. The Cricut listing does not state which cutting machines the film works with.

Choose the ZICOTO Stencil Sheets if

  • You want 24 reusable sheets for signs and craft projects.
  • You work across wood, metal, walls, glass and ceramics, including curved surfaces.
  • You cut with a cutting machine and paint the project after.

Choose the Cricut Stencil Film if

  • You want a 12 in x 12 ft roll for walls, glass, wood and canvas.
  • You want a translucent film for easy alignment.
  • You want an adhesive that removes without residue.

Choose the VViViD Stencil Vinyl if

  • You stencil with spray paint or paint techniques on rigid, smooth surfaces.
  • You want a low tack vinyl that leaves no messy or sticky residue.
  • You cut with a vinyl cutting machine or trim by hand.

For more craft machine gear, see craft machines and cutting machines.

Safety

The VViViD vinyl in this comparison is made for cutting machines and paint, not for a laser cutter. Keep vinyl away from a laser beam, ventilate while painting, and follow the listing guidance for the material you use.

Project Match

Match the project to the listing that names its surface.

  • Walls, glass, wood and canvas: Cricut Stencil Film.
  • Wooden signs, metal, walls, glass and ceramics, including curved surfaces: ZICOTO Stencil Sheets.
  • Art board, wood, drywall, glass, mounted watercolour paper and primed canvas: VViViD Stencil Vinyl.

FAQ: lasers and CNC

What vinyl is best for stencils?

The VViViD Stencil Vinyl is the vinyl pick here, formulated for stencil applications, especially spray paint and paint techniques. The ZICOTO sheets are mylar, described as an alternative to stencil vinyl sheets. The Cricut Stencil Film is stencil film, not vinyl.

Can you cut these stencil materials with a vinyl cutting machine?

The ZICOTO listing says to cut the stencils with a cutting machine. The VViViD listing states compatibility with most vinyl cutting machines, and says the vinyl can be trimmed by hand. The Cricut listing does not state which cutting machines the film works with.

Is stencil vinyl reusable?

The ZICOTO sheets are washable and reusable, per the listing. The VViViD listing does not state reuse. The Cricut listing does not state reuse.

What surfaces can you stencil on with these materials?

The Cricut listing names walls, glass, wood and canvas. The ZICOTO listing names wooden signs, artwork on metal, walls, glass and ceramics, and notes curved surfaces. The VViViD listing names art board, wood, drywall, glass, mounted watercolour paper and primed canvas, and limits adhesion to rigid, smooth surfaces.

Related: craft machines and cutting machines.

More buying guides