Computerized vs Mechanical Sewing Machine: Which One Should You Buy?
A computerized machine picks stitches through a screen or app, while a mechanical machine uses dials and levers; this guide compares the two types and lists computerized machines for stitch variety.
On this page
A computerized sewing machine picks stitches and settings through a screen, buttons or an app, while a mechanical sewing machine picks them through dials and levers, and the computerized vs mechanical sewing machine choice comes down to how much stitch variety and automation the project needs. A maker who wants many built-in stitches, automatic buttonholes and push-button control should look at a computerized machine, while a maker who wants simple dial controls and fewer electronics should look at a mechanical machine.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. LaserEngraveHQ earns a commission from purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.
What a computerized machine does
A computerized machine selects stitches through a screen, buttons or an app instead of dials, and the machines in this guide offer wide stitch libraries with automatic features. The SINGER Smart HD 9120 adds phone app control through the free CREATIVATE app, while the other three select stitches without an app. Built-in needle threaders, drop-in bobbins and speed control appear across the four machines, and the SINGER Smart HD 9120, SINGER Quantum Stylist 9960 and Janome JW8100 add a start/stop button.
What a mechanical machine does
A mechanical machine selects stitches with dials and levers, and the sewer sets stitch length and width by hand. It has no screen, no stitch library to scroll through, and no app, so the controls stay the same from project to project. A maker who sews straight seams and simple stitches, and who wants the fewest electronics between hand and needle, should look at a mechanical machine, while a maker who wants many decorative stitches should look at a computerized machine.
Computerized vs mechanical sewing machine: side-by-side
| Feature | Computerized machine | Mechanical machine |
|---|---|---|
| Stitch selection | Screen, buttons or app | Dials and levers |
| Built-in stitches listed in this guide | 100 to 600 | Not stated |
| Buttonholes | One-step styles listed | Not stated |
| Suits | Stitch variety, quilting, decorative work | Simple seams, few electronics |
How to choose between a computerized and a mechanical sewing machine
Start from the stitching: a maker who wants many built-in stitches, automatic buttonholes and app or screen control should look at a computerized machine, while a maker who wants dial controls and the fewest electronics should look at a mechanical machine. A maker who sews only straight seams can start with either type, since straight stitches appear on both. The gear below lists computerized machines in rank order, since no mechanical machine appears in the listings for this guide, so check mechanical listings separately for dial-control machines.
Gear to look at
The gear below lists the computerized machines in rank order. All four are computerized machines; no mechanical machine appears in the listings for this guide, so check mechanical listings separately for dial-control work.
SINGER Quantum Stylist 9960
The SINGER Quantum Stylist 9960 offers 600 built-in stitches and 1,172 stitch applications, including essential, stretch and decorative stitches, with mirror imaging and stitch elongation. It carries 13 fully automatic one-step buttonhole styles, 5 fonts for lettering, and 13 presser feet, plus a large extension table and a hard dust cover. A built-in automatic needle threader, a top drop-in bobbin with a transparent cover, speed control and a start/stop button round out the controls. The warranty description lists a limited 25-year warranty including 5-year coverage on electronic components and 1-year coverage on labor.
SINGER Smart HD 9120
The SINGER Smart HD 9120 connects to the free CREATIVATE app on iOS and Android for guided setup, stitch control, tutorials and project ideas, and it offers 200+ stitches organized in an app stitch library. The optional 900E embroidery attachment, sold separately, opens more than 150 free embroidery designs in a 170 mm x 100 mm hoop. A built-in needle threader, a jam-free drop and sew bobbin, a speed control lever and a start/stop button cover the onboard controls, and a straight stitch needs no app and no phone. Eco Mode puts the machine to sleep after 20 minutes of inactivity, and the listing gives a 1 Year Manufacturer warranty.
Janome JW8100
The Janome JW8100 offers 100 built-in stitches and 7 one-step buttonholes, with an LCD screen and buttons for stitch choice and a speed control slider. A 7-piece feed dog system moves fabric evenly, and the front drawer removes to reveal a free arm for sleeves and tight spaces. The box includes 22 accessories in total, including an extension table, an even feed foot, a quarter inch foot and a hard cover. The warranty description lists a 25 year limited warranty on mechanical parts, a 2 year limited warranty on electrical parts and a 1 year limited warranty on labor.
Brother CE1150 (Renewed)
The Brother CE1150, listed as renewed, offers 110 built-in stitches including 8 styles of 1-step auto-size buttonholes, with an LCD screen for stitch selection and speed control at 410 spm. It includes 7 sewing feet, including blind hem, overcasting, buttonhole, zigzag, monogramming, button sewing and zipper feet, plus an automatic needle threader and a jam resistant drop-in top bobbin. It weighs 13.75 pounds, and the listing describes a portable, lightweight package.
FAQ: lasers and CNC
Do I need a computerized machine for straight seams?
No. Straight seams work on either type, and the SINGER Smart HD 9120 notes that a straight stitch needs no app and no phone. A mechanical machine suits a maker who only needs straight seams and simple stitches.
What does a computerized machine add over dials?
A screen or app for stitch choice, a wide built-in stitch library, automatic buttonholes, and push-button features such as a needle threader, speed control and start/stop. The machines in this guide list 100 to 600 built-in stitches, and the three that state a buttonhole count list 7 to 13 one-step styles.
Can I use a phone app with any computerized machine?
No. Only the SINGER Smart HD 9120 in this guide connects to a phone app, the free CREATIVATE app on iOS and Android. The other three select stitches without an app.
Which machine here lists the highest stitch count?
The SINGER Quantum Stylist 9960, with 600 built-in stitches and 1,172 stitch applications. The SINGER Smart HD 9120 follows with 200+ stitches.
What warranty terms do these machines list?
The SINGER Quantum Stylist 9960 lists a limited 25-year warranty including 5-year coverage on electronic components and 1-year coverage on labor. The Janome JW8100 lists a 25 year limited warranty on mechanical parts, a 2 year limited warranty on electrical parts and a 1 year limited warranty on labor. The SINGER Smart HD 9120 lists a 1 Year Manufacturer warranty. No warranty term is stated for the Brother CE1150.
Related: the sewing and embroidery machines hub, best serger sewing machine, best rated beginner sewing machine, and craft machines.
