Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Underglaze vs Glaze for Pottery (2026): Which One Should You Buy?

Two underglazes and two glazes for pottery, compared by firing range, coats, finish, and food safety, with a verdict for detail work and layered color.

Underglaze vs Glaze for Pottery (2026): Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Speedball 001050 Underglaze, White, 16OZSpeedball 001050 Underglaze, White, 16OZ9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Speedball 001056 Underglaze, Royal Blue, 16OZSpeedball 001056 Underglaze, Royal Blue, 16OZ9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Mayco Stroke & Coat Wonderglazes 12-Color Set #1Mayco Stroke & Coat Wonderglazes 12-Color Set #19.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4AMACO Potters Choice Glaze, Blue Rutile PC-20AMACO Potters Choice Glaze, Blue Rutile PC-209.5/10View on Amazon

A plain mug leaves the kiln looking unfinished, and the color work starts long before the glaze firing: painted lines, sgraffito, layered color. This comparison looks at underglaze vs glaze for pottery, using the listings on both sides, and sorts out which finish fits which piece.

LaserEngraveHQ earns a commission from purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Verdict: underglaze and glaze do different jobs and can be used on the same piece: underglaze puts down painted detail, sgraffito, and watercolor effects that stay put through firing, while glaze forms the finished surface, from flowing layered color to a gloss finish. The Mayco set crosses the line, firing to gloss while staying put like an underglaze.

Machines on the list

Speedball 001050 Underglaze, White, 16OZ

Speedball 001050 Underglaze, White, 16OZ

Speedball9.5/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 16 fl oz jar of opaque white underglaze for detailed painting, sgraffito, and watercolor effects, made to fire from Cone 06 to Cone 6 and at Cone 10.

Pros

  • Opaque color that will not move or bleed
  • Wide firing range, Cone 06-6, and can fire at Cone 10
  • Lead-free and dinnerware safe when used and fired as directed
  • Suits detailed painting, sgraffito, and mishima decoration

Cons

  • One color per jar; building a palette takes more jars
  • Needs 2-3 liberal coats for best results
  • Opaque coverage hides the clay body underneath
  • Tall jar at 8.0 in high needs upright shelf space
Speedball 001056 Underglaze, Royal Blue, 16OZ

Speedball 001056 Underglaze, Royal Blue, 16OZ

Speedball9.5/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 16 fl oz jar of opaque royal blue underglaze for detailed painting, sgraffito, and watercolor effects, made to fire from Cone 06 to Cone 6 and at Cone 10.

Pros

  • Opaque color that will not move or bleed
  • Wide firing range, Cone 06-6, and can fire at Cone 10
  • Lead-free and dinnerware safe when used and fired as directed
  • Suits detailed painting, sgraffito, and mishima decoration

Cons

  • One color per jar; building a palette takes more jars
  • Needs 2-3 liberal coats for best results
  • Opaque coverage hides the clay body underneath
  • No warranty term is stated
Mayco Stroke & Coat Wonderglazes 12-Color Set #1

Mayco Stroke & Coat Wonderglazes 12-Color Set #1

Mayco9.5/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 12-pint set of gloss glazes in 12 colors, made for wet or unfired clay or bisque, firing to gloss without clear glaze.

Pros

  • 12 colors in 16 oz jars, one pint each
  • Fires to a gloss finish without clear glaze
  • Applies to wet or unfired clay or bisque
  • Tolerates overfiring without fading

Cons

  • 20.3 lb set, heavy to carry and store
  • No warranty term is stated
  • 12 jars take more shelf space than a single jar
  • Needs drying time between coats
AMACO Potters Choice Glaze, Blue Rutile PC-20

AMACO Potters Choice Glaze, Blue Rutile PC-20

AMACO9.5/10 HQ Score
i
The HQ Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 1 pint layerable mid-high fire glaze in Blue Rutile, flowing light blue where thick and breaking brown where thinner, for Cone 5-6 firing.

Pros

  • Layerable for textured work
  • Flows light blue where thick, breaks brown where thinner
  • Fires in oxidation for Cone 10 reduction effects
  • Suits all AMACO stoneware and porcelain clays

Cons

  • One color per pint; a range needs more jars
  • Mid-high fire only, Cone 5-6
  • Very fluid, so it moves where applied
  • Needs Cone 04 bisque before firing to Cone 5-6

Side by side

Model HQ Score Side Size Firing range Coats Finish Food safety
Speedball White 9.5/10 Underglaze 16 fl oz Cone 06-6, Cone 10 2-3 coats Opaque Lead-free, dinnerware safe
Speedball Royal Blue 9.5/10 Underglaze 16 fl oz Cone 06-6, Cone 10 2-3 coats Opaque Lead-free, dinnerware safe
Mayco Stroke & Coat 9.5/10 Glaze 12 pints, 16 oz each Cone 06 or 05 2-3 coats Gloss Not stated
AMACO Blue Rutile 9.5/10 Glaze 1 pint, 16 oz Cone 5-6 Not stated Flowing, breaks brown Not stated

We give each product’s specs as its manufacturer rates them; listings read 21 November 2026.

Underglaze vs glaze for pottery: how they work

Underglaze is color painted onto the piece before the glaze firing. The Speedball underglazes are opaque and will not move or bleed, made for detailed painting, sgraffito decoration, watercolor effects, free brush painting, and mishima decoration. Glaze is the glassy coating that gives the finished surface. The AMACO glaze is an active, complex liquid that flows where thick and breaks where thinner, and the Mayco glazes fire to a gloss finish without clear glaze. In this set the underglazes carry the painted design, while the glazes form the fired surface.

Firing ranges

The Speedball underglazes perform across a wide firing range, Cone 06 to Cone 6, and can fire at Cone 10. The AMACO glaze fires to Cone 5 to Cone 6, applied to Cone 04 bisque first. The Mayco glazes fire at Cone 06 or Cone 05 and can also be high-fired. The Speedball range is stated in cones, while the Mayco high-fire option gives no cone number in the listing.

Coats and coverage

The Speedball underglazes call for 2 to 3 liberal coats for best results. The Mayco glazes call for 2 to 3 coats for opacity and all-over coverage, with one coat giving a translucent finish and more coats adding opacity. The AMACO glaze is described as layerable and very fluid. Let each coat dry before the next: the Mayco listing says to let coats dry between coats and to dry completely before firing.

Finish and food safety

The Speedball underglazes dry opaque and stay where painted. The AMACO glaze flows light blue where thick and breaks brown where thinner, for textured work. The Mayco glazes fire to a gloss finish without clear glaze, and the heavy-bodied glazes level out and heal imperfections during application. On food safety, the Speedball underglazes are lead-free and dinnerware safe when used and fired as directed. Food-safety wording on these listings appears only on the Speedball jars.

Choose underglaze if

  • You paint fine detail, sgraffito, or mishima and want color that stays put.
  • You fire across a wide range, from Cone 06 to Cone 6, or at Cone 10.
  • You want lead-free color that is dinnerware safe when used and fired as directed.

Choose glaze if

  • You want flowing color that breaks over texture, like the AMACO Blue Rutile.
  • You want a gloss finish without a clear glaze, like the Mayco set.
  • You want a full color range in one set, with 12 colors for wet clay or bisque.

For more material choices, see the pottery and clay hub.

Safety

Dinnerware safety holds only when the underglaze is used and fired as directed, as the Speedball listing states. Follow the firing range on the jar, and keep food-safe claims to pieces fired as directed.

Project Match

  • Detailed painting and sgraffito: Speedball White or Royal Blue underglaze, made for detailed painting, sgraffito, watercolor effects, and mishima.
  • Layered, textured color: AMACO Blue Rutile, made for layering and textured work.
  • A full color range for wet clay or bisque: Mayco Stroke & Coat set, with 12 colors for wet or unfired clay or bisque.
  • Gloss finish without a clear glaze: Mayco Stroke & Coat, which fires to gloss without clear glaze.
  • Dinnerware: Speedball underglazes, lead-free and dinnerware safe when used and fired as directed.

FAQ: lasers and CNC

What is the difference between underglaze and glaze?

Underglaze is opaque color painted on before the glaze firing, made to stay put for detail work. Glaze is the coating that finishes the surface: the AMACO glaze flows and breaks over texture, and the Mayco glazes fire to gloss without clear glaze.

What cone does underglaze fire at?

The Speedball underglazes perform from Cone 06 to Cone 6 and can fire at Cone 10. Match the cone to the clay body and the firing schedule, and check the jar for the range.

Can you layer glaze?

The AMACO Blue Rutile is described as layerable and very fluid. The Mayco glazes are a different case: extra coats build opacity, with one coat translucent and 2 to 3 coats opaque.

Is underglaze safe for dinnerware?

The Speedball underglazes are lead-free and dinnerware safe when used and fired as directed. Keep that claim to the Speedball jars and to pieces used and fired as directed.

Related: the pottery and glass hub and the engraving materials hub.

More buying guides

Pottery and Glass ·

Best Underglazes for Pottery (2026)

Underglazes for pottery, from a 16 oz black jar to 12-color sets, compared by firing range, color range and food safety.

Pottery and Clay ·

Best Underglaze for Pottery (2026)

Underglazes for pottery compared by color range, firing range, food safety and format, from a 24-color set to a soft tip pen.

Pottery and Clay ·

Best Clay Carving Tools (2026)

Five clay carving tool sets for pottery and polymer clay, compared by piece count, material, tool length and warranty.